I have heard a lot of mixed reviews on this product, and so I was really curious to give it a try. The wand is small and you are suppose to twirl it as you apply it for 400% more volume. I did not find that to be true for me. It has great color payoff, and made my lashes look nice but there wasn't anything amazing volume wise. I will say however, that as a lower lash mascara it really worked for me. I like to use it on my lower lashes, just working it back and forth and had great volume there.

This liner has a paddle tip which you can get both a thin or thick line from one eyeliner. I liked that about it because sometimes I want a thicker line without having to go over it multiple times as we all know with eyeliner you gotta be careful it gets out of hand quickly. I liked that it applied easily, went over my shadow with dragging on my lid. I have allergy eyes, and oily lids and I was able to get about 6 hours of wear before I noticed that it was breaking apart. The inner portion of my liner was gone by the end of 8 hours but most non waterproof liners are.

I think these are both nice products, the mascara I will use on my lower lashes from now on. The liner will be used on days that I don't need a sweat proof look. I think if you have lids that are not oily and don't suffer from allergies the liner will be long lasting for sure.